What Happens When a Cheap Loan Comes Due

Picture a building owner who borrowed $10 million five years ago at a little over 4 percent. The rate was low, the payments were comfortable, and refinancing when the loan ended looked like a routine errand. 

Now the loan is ending, and the owner is shopping for a new one in a market where rates sit above 6 percent. The owner is the same and so is the building. The math has changed.

That situation is about to play out thousands of times, and it explains a lot of what is happening in commercial real estate right now.

A small gap adds up fast

CRED iQ looked at the CMBS loans coming due over the next nine months, as of late August. Their average interest rate was 5.44 percent. New loans written between May and August priced at 6.58 percent. That is a difference of about 1.1 percentage points, and on our $10 million example, it works out to roughly $114,000 more in interest every year.

For a building with healthy margins, that is an annoyance. For a building that was already stretched, it can decide whether the owner refinances or goes back to the lender and asks for more time.

Lenders have been giving people time

Since 2023, lenders have mostly answered a maturing loan by extending it or changing its terms. That kept a lot of owners out of default, and it shows in the data. KBRA's October report on rated CMBS put the share of loans in distress at 10.3 percent, which is lower than a year ago.

The numbers have stopped getting worse, and that is real progress. It also means many of the hard conversations have been postponed, because extra time only helps if something changes while you wait.

S&P Global has projected that commercial real estate loan maturities will peak at $1.26 trillion in 2027, up from $950 billion in 2024. That projection dates to 2025, so it is an estimate, but it explains why so many lenders are watching the calendar.

Not every building is in the same spot

Office space gets the most attention, for good reason. In the same CRED iQ data, office carries the largest maturing balance at $23.9 billion, and its rate gap is about 1.7 points, well above the 1.1 average. On our $10 million loan, that gap would mean roughly $172,000 more a year.

Apartments look better. KBRA reported that multifamily delinquencies declined in October. Two buildings that look alike on paper can end up in very different places depending on the city they sit in and the tenants inside them, so the national averages only go so far.

What I look at first

I started my career in newsrooms, and the habit that stuck is going to the primary source before trusting the summary. When I read about a loan coming due, I want to see the loan itself.

I come at this as a lender, so my first question is what I would hold if the owner could not refinance. The building has to be worth more than the loan at today's values, because the values from 2021 are gone. The borrower's finances matter, too, and so does the plan for repayment.

An extension deserves the same scrutiny. It gives an owner time, and time is useful when rents are rising or rates are falling. A lender who extends without a plan for how the loan gets repaid has changed the date and little else.

Why this matters beyond finance

These loans sit behind buildings that people use every day, including offices and apartments. When a loan gets resolved well, the building keeps operating and the tenants barely notice. When it does not, the building can change hands or sit half empty for a while.

The quality of the underwriting matters to more people than the lender and the owner.

The test is coming

2027 will test a lot of loans written in a different era. The ones that hold up will tend to be the ones where somebody asked the plain questions early, while there was still time to act on the answers.

This post shares my own views on market conditions and is not investment advice or an offer of any security. Figures come from the publications named above and were current when those publications were released. The $10 million example is an illustration and ignores principal payments and fees.

Dan McDonough

Founder and executive chairman at Elauwit. Helping property owners and REITs deliver delightful internet experiences to their multi-family tenants.

Next
Next

The Case for Digital Infrastructure as a Credit Asset